| Years | Professionals |
| 1861 | W. Warrington |
| 1862-1866 | J. Berry |
| 1869 | Luke Greenwood / William Shotton |
| 1870 | T.W. Hornby / G. Lynas / R. Clayton / T. Darnton / F. Randon / J. Bloomfield |
| 1870-1875 | E. Barratt |
| 1871-1873 | Henry Smith Reynolds |
| 1873 | Thomas Barnes / F. Morley / D. Eastwood / J. Hicks / E. Pooley |
| 1874-1875 | William Elliott |
| 1875-1876 | Whitehouse / Brougham |
| 1877 | G. Walton |
| 1878 | W. Bottomore / M. Myers |
| 1879-1883 | David Bookless |
| 1879 | Price |
| 1880-1884 | R. McLeod |
| 1881-1886 | Thomas Thompson |
| 1882-1886 | Jack C. Angus |
| 1885-1886 | G. Nash |
| 1887 | Irwin Smith |
| 1888 | G.H. Rhodes |
| 1889 | Irwin Smith |
| 1890 | S. Ridsdale |
| 1891-1895 | J. Gregory |
| 1896 | NYSD League Started |
| 1896-1898 | Jack Bucknell |
| 1897 | H.P. Child |
| 1898 | Jack Bucknell |
| 1899-1901 | George Turnbull |
| 1902 | Charles B. Pepper |
| 1903 | Charles E. Dench |
| 1904-1908 | Willie Tolson |
| 1909-1911 | Robert H. Brydon |
| 1912-1913 | Willie Tolson |
| 1914 | Frank E. Pestell |
| 1915-1919 | No Professionals (War) |
| 1920 | Stanley Crozier |
| 1921-1924 | Harry Turner |
| 1925-1927 | Ambrose C. Williams |
| 1928-1929 | Fred Brown |
| 1930-1931 | George Higgins |
| 1932 | Jimmy N. Lang / J.R. Milne |
| 1932-1936 | George J. Johnson |
| 1937 | Percy E. Morfee |
| 1938-1939 | No-one appointed |
| 1940-1946 | No Professionals (War) |
| 1947 | Arthur Ashwell |
| 1948 | Joe Wood |
| 1949 | James Henry Clarke |
| 1950-1956 | Paul Alexander Huntley Dobree-Carey |
| 1957-1958 | Harold Eldson |
| 1959 | J. Trevor Gibson |
| 1960-1961 | Not Known |
| 1961-1969 | Stuart H. Young |
| 1970-1972 | John G. Glassford |
| 1973 | P. David Borrill |
| 1974-1979 | John S. Waring |
| 1980-1981 | Paul W. Romaines |
| 1982-1983 | Simon P. Davis |
| 1984 | Willie S. Johnston |
| 1985 | Andrew W. Scott |
| 1986 | Steve J. Malone |
| 1987-1989 | Johnny Johnston |
| 1988 | A.J. Murphy (1 game replacement) |
| 1990-1991 | Masood Anwar |
| 1990-1991 | Mushtaq Ahmed (replacement for 7 games) |
| 1992 | Scott A Muller |
| 1993 | Abey Kuruvilla |
| 1994 | Ajay Jadeja |
| 1995-1997 | Ashok S. Patel |
| 1998-2000 | John D. Glendenen |
| 2001 | Neil Pratt / Navdeep Singh Sidhu |
| 2002 | Neil Pratt / Hanif-ur-Rehman |
| 2003 | Neil Pratt / Simon M. Guy |
| 2004-2005 | Neil Pratt / Steve Chapman |
| 2006 | Neil Pratt / Aaron Keith Heal |
| 2007 | Neil Pratt / Mandle A. Mashimbyi |
| 2008 | Neil Pratt / S.A. Agharkar |
| 2009 | Doug Mulholland / Simon M. Guy |
| 2010 | Doug Mulholland / Tariq Aziz |
| 2011 | Doug Mulholland / Rajin Saleh |
| 2012-2013 | Doug Mulholland / John Barnes |
| 2014 | Doug Mulholland / Rajin Saleh |
| 2015 | Doug Mulholland / Liam Coates |
| 2016-17 | Liam Coates / Muhammad Saad |
| 2018 | Liam Coates / Rajeewa Weerasinghe |
| 2019 | Liam Coates / Tom Hewison |
| 2020-21 | N/A |
| 2022-24 | Muhammad Saad |